
WARSAW — The Polish National Opera presented the highly anticipated world premiere of Ukrainian composer Maxim Kolomiiets’ The Mothers of Kherson (Makti Chersonia) Oct. 16 in the superb acoustic of Teatr Wielki. A joint production with the Metropolitan Opera, which will introduce it to New York audiences in April 2028, the opera’s English-language libretto, by George Brant, was inspired by accounts of Ukrainian mothers who undertook a circuitous, 3,000-mile journey to Russia in 2022 to search for and rescue their abducted children.
By all accounts, the opera opened to a full house that included Kolomiiets, Brant, and some of the mothers who risked their lives to retrieve their children. At performance’s end, the audience rose for a 20-minute standing ovation. According to an usher I spoke with, attendance decreased at the second performance. By the third performance, which I saw Oct. 23, the house was only half full, and applause and scattered cheers ended after three or so final bows of the entire cast and chorus.

The partially fictionalized story revolves around two mothers, Kateryna (Izabela Matula) and Dasha (Kamila Dutkowska), who send their teenage daughters Lilia (Hanna Sosnowska-Bill) and Olena (Weronika Wojtkowska) to a free Russian-sponsored summer camp in Crimea. Another woman, the elderly, partially disabled, and equally strong-willed Olha (Małgorzata Walewska), learns of the departure of her granddaughter, Inna.
Once communication with the children ceases and reports of abducted children reach the mothers and Olha, they unite with other women to undertake a perilous bus ride to “Camp Friendship” in Crimea to rescue the children from the Camp Principal (Tadeusz Szlenkier).
During the journey, Olha’s strength slowly gives out. While a few mothers, including the cunning Kateryna, ultimately succeed in freeing their children, others return to Ukraine carrying the pain that their offspring are among the 18,000 or more young people who remain missing to this day.
The episodic, sometimes polemical libretto that Polish director Barbara Wysocka has described as a “documentary road opera” is frequently more formulaic than gripping. Although the production includes — among its many videos and projections — historic, emotionally intense black-and-white footage taken by mothers who undertook the journey and climaxes in a breathtaking rescue scene whose content is unfortunately revealed in the online synopsis (which I urge you not to read), Brant’s dialogue is often so predictable that one can easily complete some characters’ sentences before they do.
This is not to suggest that plot predictability, absurd situations, and banal dialogue are uncommon in the world of opera. Despite such flaws, what sets the best operas apart from others equally handicapped by their librettos is their transcendent music, and the opportunities it presents to singers who have the gifts necessary to transforming notes into high art.

Kolomiiets’ music for The Mothers of Kherson, which includes numerous arias and touching snippets of a Ukrainian folk lullaby, Ukrainian folk melodies, and Ukrainian-like liturgical laments, is intentionally accessible and agreeable. The concluding chorus, a lullaby performed with stirring conviction by the chorus of the Polish National Opera, Artos Children’s Choir, and everyone onstage, serves as a rousing anthem of determination that, on the night I attended, brought the entire audience to its feet. Its effect was rendered even more powerful by the closing projection: “Dedicated to the over 20,000 Ukrainian children who have not yet returned.”
But the powerful closing chorus and a heartbreaking story are not enough. Under the baton of Keri-Lynn Wilson, the founder and music director of the Ukrainian Freedom Orchestra who is married to Metropolitan Opera general director Peter Gelb, nothing much lingered in the memory.
In one too many arias, the female leads sang forte until their aria’s final bars, which were sung softly, with floated highs. As lovely as they sounded, the effect of repeated final diminuendos ultimately became as predictable as the libretto itself.

The performance had other problems, some of which may be addressed by the Met’s cast. Although Polish National Opera’s singers were solid, their vocal production was so homogenized that they seemed to have attended the same vocal academy or worked with the same teacher.
Ultimately, there were only three vocal standouts: the veteran Walewska, whose contralto-like low tones emanated gravitas and often tore at the heart; the especially strong, handsomely voiced Icelandic baritone Ólafur Sigurðarson as the ever-persevering “elderly” bus driver; and the young tenor Adrian Domarecki as the successfully indoctrinated young Kostya, who tries to persuade his fellow campers to remain in Russia.



























