
BOSTON — If anyone has experience negotiating the treacherous intersection of artificial intelligence and classical music, please step forward.
Enter Tod Machover.
Machover, composer and director of Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Media Lab, has spent a lifetime seeking equilibrium between acoustic and electronic sounds. His latest attempt, already and not yet, a concerto for orchestra and electronics that engages AI as a real-time musical partner, received its world premiere Oct. 24 by the Boston Symphony Orchestra and conductor Kent Nagano in Symphony Hall.
The work follows a path Machover first took half a century ago. The concerto engages the orchestra as live performers and as collaborators with his own artificial intelligence software. Machover placed a computer-managed sound enhancement system amid the orchestra (a system developed and controlled by MIT’s Manaswi Mishra) and populated Symphony Hall with surround-sound speakers.

Machover brings human intelligence, and experience, to these experiments. He spent seven years in the ’80s with Pierre Boulez’s electronic-music ensemble, IRCAM. From there he went to MIT, where he has been director of the artistically adventurous Media Lab for 45 years. His compositional studies include work with Dallapiccola, Carter, Babbitt, and Sessions.
Machover’s seven operas have involved taped sounds, invented electronic instruments, and robots (in 2010’s Death and the Powers). Brain Opera (1996) explores the ideas of Marvin Minsky, among the first to posit that “agents” may develop self-sufficient intelligence. VALIS, a 1987 opera based on the science fiction of Philip K. Dick, explores the same ideas.
His new concerto blends the orchestra, the AI system, and recordings in an unrepeatable live performance. The acoustic instruments play triggers and offer rudimentary improvisations; the AI software absorbs and responds. The improvisations, and the AI responses, will differ in each performance — leading to endless premieres.
Three movements are played without pause. The first foregrounds the busy and large acoustic ensemble, pitting brass and winds against the strings, with minimal AI involvement. Because of its brassy, heavily punctuated phrases and accessible energy, the movement invokes (without the AI) the best-known Concerto for Orchestra, Bartók’s, which premiered in this same room in 1944.
As the back-of-stage instruments are gradually overwhelming the strings in the first movement, the score warns “Get Ready for AI Solo!” (AI gets its own staff). For the first movement at least, the AI impact seemed limited to enhancing the brass.
AI’s presence increases throughout the second movement, in which the software reacts to a dozen or so improvisations, which are passed among the orchestra’s principal players. It’s a play-and-listen exercise, as AI recreates tone colors but also manufactures its own harmonies and counterpoint, after “listening.” At one point, a moving chorale emerges, a melismatic swirling effect. Further on, a sampled vocal recording gets triggered, using additional electronics managed by collaborator Ana Schon at a soundboard.

The sophistication of the concept did not fully translate to complexity in the composition. Instrumental soloists were encouraged to improvise differently from each other. The improvisations were all based on two-, three- or four-note suggested pitches, and did not fruitfully engage the expertise of the acoustic musicians, reducing them to sonic triggers.
As a listening exercise, it could readily be compared to theme and variations, or a call and response, but the origin of the sounds was impossible to distinguish after a short while.
In the finale, AI involvement increases as the acoustic participation simplifies. A brief AI cadenza — more appropriately a compendium of AI’s greatest hits from the previous half-hour — interrupts the chaos of the third movement. That chaos gets visualized as well — each of the first and second violins are playing different improvisations, like a tableau vivant of two dozen musicians disjointedly playing two dozen different works. The orchestra responds with polite professionalism, but just that.
Viewing the concerto as proof, or lack, of AI’s artistic effectiveness would be mistaken. The work continues experiments that are rooted in early sound enhancement, like the first electric guitarist who plugged in and listened to feedback. Nearly a century of electronic music-making has made significant artistic additions to composed music; Machover and the MIT team feel like advance scouts, evaluating the suitability of more new terrain.
Nagano added personal links to the program, which included Mendelssohn’s Hebrides overture and Reformation Symphony, along with another new work, Argentine composer Alex Nante’s Ein feste Burg.

Nagano began after intermission with Nante’s orchestral imagining of Bach’s famous chorale harmonization. Nante’s work, commissioned at the request of Nagano, who led the world premiere in 2025 with Dresdener Philharmonie, was intended to reference not only its origins in Bach but also its striking inclusion in Mendelssohn’s Reformation, where it sweeps majestically into the final movement. Nagano asked Nante not to alter Bach’s harmonization but simply to arrange it for orchestra.
Nante changed little of Bach, but with greatly original effect: From the high, soft, and slowest possible string texture in the opening, this was its own work. Leaving Bach tonally intact, Nante’s introspective setting deepened the unvoiced text. Bach’s harmonization leveled up the audience through Nante, AI might say, information that might never be lost.
Strikingly, Nagano led without pause from Nante’s one-movement meditation into Mendelssohn’s symphony. It caused some applause confusion but linked the unmistakable music history in a kind of performance symbolism. The Reformation Symphony hardly makes easy listening, with its stormy tonal centers D and D minor, and its turbulence of ideas and rhythms. But when principal flute Lorna McGhee articulated the “Ein feste Burg” melody in the finale, hearing was made anew, again. Perhaps AI heard it as well.
























