
NEW YORK — Yannick Nézet-Séguin launched his season-long cycle of Mahler’s nine symphonies with an electrifying performance of the Fifth Symphony with the Philadelphia Orchestra at Carnegie Hall on Oct. 13. Judging from this opening concert, the performances promise to be technically brilliant and emotionally charged, with the conductor’s musical personality front and center.
Large-scale works are the canvases on which Nézet-Séguin can be most expansive and idiosyncratic. He is a master of detail but sometimes gets carried away in the heat of the moment, resulting in a smudged entrance, a momentary loss of cohesion, or sheer indulgence in torrents of sound. For some, this may be maddening, but his interpretations are never prosaic and can, at times, be transcendent.
In the Funeral March that opens the Fifth Symphony, stark trumpet calls immediately established the symphony’s monumental character, while the strings’ crisp dotted rhythms propelled the music forward. Together, they conveyed the agitation and vehemence Mahler demanded. The second movement surged with restless energy, the alert woodwinds piercing the tumult and the cellos lending warmth and lyricism. It ended with a glowing brass chorale, offering respite rather than triumph.
After robust, bronze-hued horn calls, the Scherzo erupted in a jarring, frenzied collision of the almost diabolical, Klezmer-infused Austrian ländler and agitated, swirling Viennese waltz. Principal horn Jennifer Montone deftly navigated the torrents of sound with glowing solos, no small feat given the energy Nézet-Séguin unleashed.
The Adagietto, scored for strings and harp, is often described as Mahler’s love letter to his future wife, Alma. Under Nézet-Séguin’s baton, its long, arching lines unfolded with ethereal beauty. Rather than mining the music for greater passion, he favored an intimacy devoid of undue sentiment. Mahler composed “Ich bin der Welt abhanden gekommen” around the same time, yet the two works convey different sentiments: The song has an air of finality, while the Adagietto speaks of affection and bliss. Both share a stillness and quiet profundity, qualities Nézet-Séguin captured without sacrificing the movement’s emotional immediacy.

The conductor’s vision reached fruition in the Rondo-Finale, which completed the symphony’s vast emotional arc from tragedy to an affirmation of life. One of its simpler pleasures was the witty conversation among the solo woodwinds. Earlier themes returned in fresh guises, most memorably in the resplendent brass statement of the chorale. Nézet-Séguin brought clarity to the complex contrapuntal writing and drove the coda inexorably toward a resounding, victorious close.
Over the coming season, Nézet-Séguin will lead the Philadelphia Orchestra, the Met Orchestra, and the Vienna Philharmonic in Mahler’s other eight numbered symphonies at Carnegie Hall and the Metropolitan Opera. Das Lied von der Erde, generally considered part of Mahler’s symphonic output, and the unfinished Tenth Symphony are not included, but it’s going to be quite a journey.
The concert opened with Webern’s Im Sommerwind, a rarely heard work that was his first substantial composition for orchestra. Although Webern would become one of the 20th century’s most radical musical innovators, that transformation lay in the future in 1904. Forgotten for decades, the work was rediscovered in 1961 and premiered the following year with Eugene Ormandy conducting the Philadelphia Orchestra.

Webern composed it while spending the summer at his family’s estate in Carinthia, immersed in the landscape that inspired Bruno Wille’s poem of the same name. Like Webern’s score, the poem evokes a summer breeze sweeping through woods and fields, ultimately dissolving human unrest into a state of almost mystical repose.
Under Nézet-Séguin’s direction, gentle winds unfolded in long, arching phrases, giving way to sprightly woodwind solos, melting trumpet tones, and sensuous playing from concertmaster David Kim. Together, these elements created a lush, dreamlike atmosphere that gradually subsided into a whisper. Webern the revolutionary was nowhere to be heard.
The calm was shattered by Julia Wolfe’s Liberty Bell, co-commissioned by the Philadelphia Orchestra and Carnegie Hall to commemorate America’s 250th anniversary. The Liberty Bell rang from colonial days until 1846, when an attempt to repair a crack left it unusable. Since then, it has remained a powerful symbol of freedom, something people came to see rather than hear. The struggle for liberty, as Wolfe writes, is neither quiet nor tidy, but a messy, boisterous affair, and she revels in bold, forceful gestures.
Wolfe wanted rambunctious and raucous; Nézet-Séguin and the orchestra delivered. Crashing slabs of sound collided with bells, some discordant and fractured, others jubilant. Charles Ives came to mind in the multilayered, often violent clashes. The most effective passages featured tolling bells answered by sharp, whipping gestures from the violins. The rhythmically charged score offered few lyrical interludes, and they were soon interrupted. The work’s abrupt end left a bell resonating through the hall. Nézet-Séguin welcomed the composer to the stage to share in the applause.
























