In Bond’s ‘Clara’, An Artist Is Seen Becoming Herself

A scene from the world premiere of Victoria Bond’s ‘Clara’ in Baden-Baden.
(Production photos by Jochen Klenk)

BADEN-BADEN – Clara Schumann’s early 200th-birthday present was a new chamber opera about her life, premiered on April 14 at the Osterfestspiele in Baden-Baden, where the brilliant musician, best known as the wife of Robert Schumann, spent some of her most productive years. Victoria Bond’s new opera Clara, on a libretto by Barbara Zinn Krieger, portrays the life of a brilliant but too-little-known artist who “had it all” in an era when a woman was expected to serve the man in her life at the expense of her own needs and ambitions.

The winsome soprano Theresa Immerz portrayed Clara Schumann.

Clara Wieck (1819-96) was one of the most revered concert pianists of the 19th century as well as a fine composer. Her father, Friedrich Wieck, a well-known Leipzig music teacher, exploited her prodigious talents from an early age to showcase his pedagogical methods. Clara made her public debut at the Gewandhaus when she was 11 and toured extensively throughout Europe during her teens, playing her own compositions (as one did) as well as music written by others. Her playing earned praise from luminaries within and beyond the world of music, and in her lifetime she gave more than 1,300 concerts. Her thoughtful repertoire choices and expressive keyboard technique transformed the piano recital from primarily a display of virtuosity to a more serious artistic enterprise.

When Robert Schumann heard the 9-year-old Clara play at a private concert, the 18-year-old was so impressed that he abandoned his law studies to become Friedrich’s student, moving into the Wieck home. Friedrich recognized Robert and Clara’s growing friendship as a potential threat to Clara’s career and sent Robert away after a year, but the two remained secretly in contact. When Robert asked for her hand, Friedrich refused violently, even threatening to shoot him. After conflict-filled years and a lawsuit resolved in their favor, the couple finally married on the day before Clara turned 21.

Even while bearing Robert eight children and managing the household, Clara continued to tour and compose; her concert income gave Robert time to write his own music, especially as emerging signs of mental illness made him a pariah in professional circles. Times were turbulent, and they moved from Berlin to Dresden and then to Düsseldorf in 1850, where Robert was committed to an asylum after a suicide attempt in 1854. He died two years later, and Clara, not yet 40, moved to Berlin and resumed touring. She bought a cottage in Baden-Baden near that of Brahms, a protégé of Robert’s and friend of the couple who was especially devoted to Clara. She spent her last years in Frankfurt, dying at age 76 after a long and fruitful career, much of which was devoted to promoting Robert’s music.

Robert (Johannes Fritsche) and Clara (Theresa Immerz ) in a dramatic moment.

It’s hardly surprising that a figure like Clara should resonate for composer Bond. The multi-talented New York-based composer, conductor, presenter, and lecturer was the first woman to graduate from Juilliard’s conducting program. Her annual Cutting Edge Concerts series has provided over 20 years of new music performances in New York. Among her own compositions, Bond’s 2001 opera Mrs. President profiles another singular 19th-century woman, one who dared to run for the nation’s highest office even before women could vote. Bond composed Clara over several years while in residence at the Brahms house in Baden-Baden.

Bond’s opera emphasizes Clara’s inner life and the conflicts of a woman struggling to balance the demands of those who depend on her against her rising consciousness of her own needs. For the young production team – director Carmen C. Kruse, Eleni C. Konstantatou, sets and costumes, and Rebekka Meyer, dramaturgy – Clara’s musicianship is secondary: With no piano on stage, we never see anyone playing or composing music. Clara exists in relation to the three main men in her life – her father, Robert, and Brahms – as she matures out of docile acceptance of their expectations to recognizing and claiming the legitimacy of her artistic and personal worth.

The stage held a seven-panel glass structure that rotated around a platform, furnished with a rock, a few birch trees, and sand, rather like a large twelve-sided terrarium with missing panels. Lighting turned the glass transparent or reflective, and the position in rotation gave the impression of greater or lesser intimacy. Before each scene, a pantomime at the back of the stage (largely obscured from my view by set elements) introduced the theme of the following sequence. Over ten scenes (plus prologue and epilogue), as Clara works out the meaning of her life, she becomes more voluble and has more and more to sing.

Clara Schumann as photographed by Franz Hanfstaengl ca.1850.

The music is largely tonal and makes extensive use of themes evoking music by Schumann or Brahms (and, I presume, Clara herself), often quoting it directly. As the drama intensifies, the familiar material is transformed into something more dissonant, with harsh instrumental writing and insistent repetition, a device that also suggests Robert’s obsessions and growing sense of persecution. Clara’s inner monologues often use a chant-like style reminiscent of Poulenc, while her outward-looking solos and duets are more melodic. The final scene, wherein the recently widowed Clara calmly vows to dedicate her life to bringing Robert’s work to the world, is based on themes from Frauenliebe und -leben, the song cycle Robert wrote the year the couple married.

Seven young artists from music schools in the Baden-Württenburg district filled the eight roles plus chorus parts. As Clara, the winsome soprano Theresa Immerz tackled the substantial role with sweet lyricism, sparkling high notes, and clear diction. Baritone Johannes Fritsche conveyed the ardor and unease of Robert, while Pascal Zurek was persuasive as Clara’s loving but irascible father. Tenor Patrik Hornak was notable in the relatively short role of Brahms. Occasionally musical climaxes pushed the young singers to their vocal limits; I hope the work can one day be staged with more seasoned artists better equipped for the big moments.

Conductor Michael Hasel (flute player in the Berlin Philharmonic) brought out the romantic sweep of the piece. The twelve-member ensemble of apprentice musicians from the Berlin Philharmonic’s Karajan Academy gave the impression of a larger orchestra, thanks in part to winds and horns that provided the colors of a romantic orchestra. Lilli Lorenz, Holger Stolz, and young Kaylee Austin were the poised actors who added subtext to the drama.

After three performances during the 2019 Easter Festival, Clara will have eight more performances at Theater Baden-Baden in the original version with piano trio May 10-June 15. For information go here.

Susan Brodie writes about music, the arts, and life from New York City and Paris. Follow her at @Susan Brodie (Twitter) and Toi Toi!

A scene from the world premiere of Victoria Bond’s opera ‘Clara’ in Baden-Baden.