Did Fleming Play Fast, Loose With Anthem? You Bet
By Arthur Kaptainis
A lot of money was riding on the outcome Sunday evening. I refer, of course, to the duration of “The Star-Spangled Banner” as sung by Renée Fleming.
One popular over/under betting line was two minutes and 25 seconds – a time within sight of Alycia Keys’ noteworthy 2013 Super Bowl mark of 2:35.
Some might argue that all bets are off for R&B singers, who are likely to follow the curvature of the melody instinctively, add fanciful decorations at will and hold notes for as long as it suits them. Opera singers follow a beat.
But which beat did Fleming follow? Not the three-four time signature of the usual version of the melody, as codified by a committee (including John Philip Sousa) in 1917 and adopted (along with words by Francis Scott Key) as the U.S. national anthem in 1931.
Nor the six-four meter seen in a c. 1790 publication of “The Anacreontic Song” (to which this tune, composed by the Englishman John Stafford Smith before 1780, was originally attached).
Rather Fleming punched it out in a solemn four-four – common time – stretching the first beat into two. The effect can be heard most clearly at the words “And the rockets’ red glare.” In Fleming’s version, at the 1:45 mark, this line comes out distinctly as: “And the rawwww-kets’ red glare.”
There are smaller rhythmic nips and tucks, as well there might be in any vocal performance. And the four-four tread, with its attendant first-beat distortion, does not last. At the words “Oh, say, does that star-spangled banner yet wave,” Fleming picks up the tempo, or at least seems to, by reverting to the usual (and more energetic) three-four time. The fermatas – pauses – on “wave” and “free” are traditional. As for the flourish on “brave” – the final word of the poem (or its first stanza) – this can surely be accepted as reasonable musico-poetic license.
It should be recognized that three-four time is not entirely sacrosanct. Edwin Eugene Bagley‘s National Emblem March incorporates a feisty duple-meter rendering of the first 12 notes of “The Star-Spangled Banner.” This composition (otherwise free of quotation) dates from 1902.
By my stopwatch Fleming’s rendition of the anthem (including a 10-second instrumental introduction) landed at 2:12. It was a soaring and noble performance, and distinctly a good thing for the public image of operatic performers. But without the time-signature switcheroo it would never have crossed the two-minute mark. I plan to discuss the matter with my local bookmaker.
Arthur Kaptainis writes about music for The Gazette (Montreal) and the National Post (Canada).Date posted: February 5, 2014
Search this site
CLASSICAL VOICE NORTH AMERICA – LOOK AROUND!
Welcome to Classical Voice North America (CVNA), an online journal of classical music criticism and commentary written by the expert members of the Music Critics Association of North America (MCANA), with occasional guest contributors. We aim to convey the richness of musical life in the U.S. and Canada at a time when traditional print media is shrinking, and to bring classical music to life via digital images, audio samples, video and more. Full Story →
Are you a music writer? Please join us. CVNA is writer-run, writer-written, and writer-friendly.
If you like what you see, become one of our sponsors. No contribution is too small!
We want to hear from you. Questions? Suggestions? Tell us at CVNA.email@example.com.
Disc and Stream
Rejecting Bernstein’s disjointed operatic approach, Michael Tilson Thomas’ recording is all of a piece, the sound of 1957 Broadway stretching confidently into tragic territory instead of a work at war with itself. Richard S. Ginell reports.
In recording circles, May 2014 will be remembered as the Berlin Philharmonic’s new spring. A bold Schumann project under Simon Rattle is the orchestra’s first venture as a go-it-alone label. Nancy Malitz reports.
Joining the go-it-alone recording trend, the Seattle Symphony under Ludovic Morlot has issued an all-American release including Elliott Carter’sInstances, written for them at the unbelievable age of 103. Richard S. Ginell reports.
Stories We Like: Recommended by Members
Has veneration of Beethoven stifled his successors? -- By Alex Ross at the New Yorker
United focus, local talent, help Utah Opera find success -- By Whitney Butters at the Deseret News
Boston's Handel and Haydn Society celebrates 200 years -- By Andrea Shea at the Artery (WBUR)
Does classical music sound better when you're high? -- By Chris Walker at OC Weekly
Stop sanitizing, and show the great works as they were created -- By Philip Kennicott at the Washington Post
Protesters disrupt St. Louis Symphony with song for Michael Brown -- By Ed Mazza at the Huffington Post
Gustavo Dudamel leads Mahler's Fifth in Los Angeles -- By Mark Swed at the Los Angeles Times
Dark, funny, musically vibrant ‘Don Giovanni’ raises the curtain on new Lyric Opera season -- By Lawrence B. Johnson at Chicago On the Aisle
Toronto's $32-million Integral House was built for music -- By Robert Everett-Green at the Globe and Mail
Alan Gilbert nears completion of his Carl Nielsen cycle with the New York Philharmonic -- By Anthony Tommasini at the New York Times
Robert Spano and Atlanta mayor Kasim Reed urge ASO and musicians to resolve conflict -- By Jenny Jarvie at ArtsATL
Mozart, Adams Combine for Perfect Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra Opening -- By Mary Ellyn Hutton at Music in Cincinnati
Inaugural concert ushers in the Nelsons era for the Boston Symphony -- By David Wright at Boston Classical Review
Quire Cleveland presents exquisite vocal exhibit of Flemish Renaissance Polyphony -- By Daniel Hathaway at Cleveland Classical
Bach, Played in Living Color: From Christian Tetzlaff, Violin Sonatas and Partitas -- By James R. Oestreich at the New York Times
Musicians go to bat for threatened Conservatoire, seen as valuable training ground for top Quebec talent -- By Arthur Kaptainis at the Montreal Gazette
In Mozart’s 'Don Giovanni,' director Robert Falls sees a complex figure worthy of Shakespeare -- By Lawrence B. Johnson at Chicago On the Aisle
New Orchestre Symphonique de Montreal disc is more crossover than classical -- By Arthur Kaptainis at the Montreal Gazette
Miami Lyric Opera offers vibrant, semi-staged 'Un ballo in maschera' -- By Lawrence Budmen at South Florida Classical Review
Author Robert Freeman says schools aren't building classical audiences -- By Mark Kanny at the Pittsburgh Tribune-Gazette
Atlanta Symphony Orchestra's crisis matters everywhere -- By Tom Service at the Guardian
The trouble with 'Klinghofer' isn't quite what you think -- By Justin Davidson at New York magazine
Met opera with new contract gears up for season that nearly wasn't -- By Anne Midgette for the The Washington Post
South Carolina Philharmonic funds commission through Kickstarter -- By Amanda Coyne at the State
'The Persians' of Aeschylus Premieres at Getty Villa -- By Rodney Punt at LA Opus
White Lights Festival presents spiritual journey in New York -- By Anthony Tommasini at the New York Times
Colorado Symphony drops tuxedos and brings drinks into the hall -- By Ray Mark Rinaldi at the Denver Post
St. Teresa Honored in Dolora Zajick's 'Roads to Zion'-- By Rodney Punt at San Francisco Classical Voice
Barbara Pentland's opera 'The Lake' is adapted to lakeside site -- By Marsha Lederman at the Globe and Mail
Wolf Trap Opera closes season with surreal double-bill -- By Charles T. Downey at Ionarts
Cleveland Orchestra hits the mark with first Summers@Severance concert -- By Mark Satola at the Plain Dealer
Speight Jenkins recalls highs and lows at Seattle Opera -- By Melinda Bargreen at the Seattle Times
A chorister speaks to the Met's financial challenges -- By Mark MacNamara at San Francisco Classical Voice
Amid all the fretting about classical music's future, some worries about its past -- By Tim Smith at the Baltimore Sun
Pianist Christina Petrowska Quilico finds peace in contemporary music -- By Natasha Gauthier at the Ottawa Citizen
Sacramento Philharmonic and Opera scrap fall season -- By Edward Ortiz at the Sacramento Bee
Immortal Beloved: Review of Jan Swafford's 'Beethoven' -- By Jeremy Denk at the New York Times Sunday Book Review
Book Review: Jan Swafford's 'Beethoven: Anguish and Triumph' -- By Edmund Morris at The Wall Street Journal
‘Baby Doe’ remains relevant through Chautauqua Opera’s remarkable staging -- By Arthur Kaptainis in The Chautauquan Daily
Longtime Chicago symphony executive named CEO of San Diego Symphony -- By Nancy Malitz at Chicago On the Aisle
Too Little Gershwin in 'The Gershwins' Porgy and Bess at the Muny -- By Chuck Lavazzi at KDHX.org